Middle Cay Eleuthera

$35,000 /Per Week
SKU: Middle Cay
Property type: Villa / House


  • Air-Conditioning
  • Beachfront
  • Dock
  • Generator
  • Private Dock
  • Swimming Pool
  • Water Front


The ultimate in luxury and privacy on a Private Island! This island paradise gives the opportunity to combine the peaceful solitude of your island with amenities nearby. Price includes daily boat rides to Harbour Island(twice). One excursion of your choice, like feed the pigs. One 4 hour session of boat tubing or water skiing.
Middle Cay, located near N. Eleuthera and from Harbour Island. Airport Code-ELH. Groceries can be bought at islands nearby.

The space

Middle Cay is a luxurious, private island just off the coast of Harbour Island. With a coconut tree grove, two villas, and daily housekeeping. This two-acre island combines five-star amenities with a secluded location for the ultimate Caribbean getaway.

The island has two docks, so guests can dock their sailboats, yachts, or rentals with ease. One dock even has an automatic boat lift. A working lighthouse adds nautical charm, a walkway winds around the entire island, and a fire pit makes s’mores a cinch. Fishing gear, a canoe, a stand up paddle board, and three kayaks are perfect for spending the day on the sea. The surrounding islands are known for their pink sand beaches, coral reefs, and shipwrecks, so take advantage of Middle Cay’s snorkeling equipment to discover an underwater paradise. There are boat rides twice a day to Harbour Island, which offers jet ski, boat, bicycle, and golf cart rentals, as well as several restaurants and beaches. If guests stay for a week, they can choose two complimentary 4-hour activities: go water tubing, water skiing, feed the pigs in Meek’s Patch, go underwater diving with a Yamaha Sea Scooter, or tour nearby islands.

Middle Cay has two homes, and both have WiFi and air-conditioning. The Main House has an open kitchen and dining space with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a dining table that seats 8. A chef is included in the rental along with serving staff that is apart from the normal housekeeping staff. Its living room has a flatscreen cable TV and opens to a private patio. Outside, there’s a pool and an outdoor shower. In the Cottage, there’s a common area with beautiful, exposed wooden beams and tile floors. The living room has plush furnishings and a flatscreen cable TV, and there’s dining at the bar and main table. It opens to the patio and has three walls of windows that reveal ocean views. The kitchen has stainless steel appliances, a coffeemaker, and a mixer.

The Main House has four bedrooms and the Cottage has three bedrooms. In the Main House, there’s a spacious master suite with a king bed, three walls of ocean views, a private patio, a lounge, and an ensuite bathroom. The second suite has two double beds, a window seat, and an ensuite bathroom. The third suite has two twin beds, ocean views, and a hall bath. The fourth suite has a king bed and an ensuite bathroom. In the Cottage, there’s a king suite with exterior access, ocean views, and an ensuite bathroom. The second suite has two double beds, exterior access, and an ensuite bathroom. The third suite is ideal for children, with a twin bunk, trundle bed, and a half bath in the hall. Daily housekeeping is provided.

Middle Cay is highly accessible. From the airport, its a five-minute taxi ride to the nearest dock and then a two-minute boat ride to Middle Cay. This island provides the ultimate in privacy and luxury, as well as easy access to activities and provisions.
Please Note – Listing includes BOTH the homes on the cay, DAILY housekeeping. Boat rides twice a day to Harbour Island. Also includes one outing for 4 hours for every 3 day rental, like feed the pigs, or a session of water tubing or water skiing, cruising to neighboring islands.

Our new 34 foot Intrepid boat is now included in the rental but fuel will be the responsibility of the guests. Our captain is available for 7 hours daily at one stretch and if needed longer there will be a $50 per hour charge.

Both Kitchens are stocked with basic spices. The fridge is stocked with basic condiments like Ketchup, mayo, mustard, soy sauce, steak sauce.

There are also boat taxis running from 6 am to 11:30 pm, that can take you around should you wish to do so.

Guest access

All areas of the island are open for guests.

The peace and relaxation you experience on the island is beyond words. All this while having easy access to two of the main islands in the Bahamas.

2021 Rates:

Security deposit:  $15,000.00

Feb 24 2021 to Aug 31, 2021 minimum night 3, weekly rate $35,000

Sept 1 to Oct 31, 2021 minimum night 3, weekly rate $21,000

Nov 1 2021 to Dec 16, 2021 minimum night 3, weekly rate $35,000

Dec 16 to Jan 5, 2022 minimum night 7, weekly rate $85,000

Video tour

Contact the Agent